Testimonials

    ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 5.0 

I had a great experience with these caterers. They were flexible in arranging phone call meetings in the lead up to the big day as I was not around for a lot of the build up. We got to meet in person twice and I was amazed by how much of a well-oiled machine they were in planning out the meeting. My husband and I had a specific order of events in mind regarding the timing of the intros/first dance/meal and dessert, and although it wasn't what the caterer was used to doing, they made our vision work. They worked well with our DJ to help the evening move along seamlessly. The food and appetizers were great as well!

    ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 5.0 

My new husband and I were recently married at The Brotherhood Winery. We hired Inn Credible Caters and it was the one of the best decisions we ever made. Kayla was amazing!!! She was accommodating, professional, helpful, and did I mention amazing. She set up everything beautifully and packed up everything too. She checked in on us often during the wedding to see if we needed anything. She made the whole experience fun and less stressful. The food was 'Inncredible'. My guests raved about all the food! (cocktail hour and main meals) I even heard from some guests it was the best food they ever had at a wedding. I highly recommend Inn Credible Caterers!

    ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 5.0 

This was my 4th child getting married but the first that we needed an outside caterer for. We made the right choice with Inn Credible.....they were "incredible"!! From the first time we met them over a year before the wedding right through to the end of the wedding last week Frank and Trish delivered on everything and made the process seamless. On the day of the wedding Eileen was our Matire'd and she was unbelievable. When we were back at the hotel after the wedding my daughter (the bride) made it a point to let me know how incredible Elieen was. She was watching over her all night to be sure she had whatever she needed so she could throughly enjoy her own wedding, which she did.

  ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 5.0 

I had a great experience with these caterers. They were flexible in arranging phone call meetings in the lead up to the big day as I was not around for a lot of the build up. We got to meet in person twice and I was amazed by how much of a well-oiled machine they were in planning out the meeting. My husband and I had a specific order of events in mind regarding the timing of the intros/first dance/meal and dessert, and although it wasn't what the caterer was used to doing, they made our vision work. They worked well with our DJ to help the evening move along seamlessly. The food and appetizers were great as well!

    ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 5.0 

My husband and I recently got married at the Brotherhood Winery and the night was perfect, mainly because of Kayla and InnCredible Caterers. Hiring InnCredible Caterers was one of the best wedding decisions we ever made. Kayla was amazing throughout the entire planning process, and especially the night of our wedding. She was always available and promptly answered our countless emails and phone calls with a positive attitude, while always making us feel at ease. Kayla, along with our maître d’ were both present at our wedding. They took total care of all of the organizational aspects of the evening so that Jon and I were able to spend the entire evening simply enjoying our special day with all of our friends and family. Kayla took great care setting up all of our personal items with her team and made the venue look fabulous. She organized my wedding party for the ceremony and personally took care of Jon and me throughout the evening. Kayla even helped my mother bustle my wedding gown! In addition to all of this, Kayla and our maître d’ made sure all of our guests were well taken care of all night. If you want a total stress-free wedding with a very positive, dynamic, supportive, and professional caterering team, you must use Kayla and InnCredible Caterers. They are absolutely the BEST!!

    ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 5.0 

Let me preface by saying my Italian parents and in laws were a little skeptical when my husband and I decided to break away from a traditional "hall wedding". We opted for a catered wedding through Inncredible Caterers at Brotherhood Winery. As you can see by my 5 star review no one was disappointed in the slightest. Food is very important to our families so our expectations were very high. To say that Inncredible Caterers did a great job is an understatement. Working with Kayla was the best part about planning the wedding. I cannot say enough positive words about her and what she did for us. She is so organized, responsive and on top of her game. She made me feel like I was the only bride she was working with when I know very well she works with multiple brides every weekend. Our wedding not only looked perfect thanks to her attention to detail but the food and service was amazing. The day of the wedding I didn't stress about one thing because her and her team were on top of everything. The day went so smoothly my husband and I wish we could go back and do it all over again!

    ★ ★ ★ ★ ★5.0 
We worked with Frank and his team for our May 2018 wedding. When looking for a caterer, we knew we needed someone that provided full service (rental and day of coordination). After searching all over and quoting out about 13 different caterers, we decided to go with Inn Credible Caterers. They offered (by far) the most food for our money. Throughout the whole planning process, Frank was extremely responsive and did multiple venue visits with us– even cutting short a vacation because it was the only weekend I could do. The venue was very bare bones, so it involved a ton of logistics– which Frank helped us work through every step of the way. 

As for the food, we could not have been happier. We wanted to do Mexican for our cinco de mayo wedding and Frank helped us create a completely custom menu. They were able to accommodate my husband’s very severe gluten allergy and my vegetarianism while still making the menu delicious. We were extremely happy at the tasting, but the food was even better on the wedding day– we didn’t think that was possible! Our guests are still raving about the food and the service. A few of our guests said the chicken enchiladas were “the best thing they’ve ever eaten”. Not a bad response to wedding food. Everyone left with very full stomachs. 

Trish was our day-of coordinator and I can’t say enough about her helpfulness and attention to detail. She made sure the ask important questions before all the craziness started and I honestly did not have a single worry the entire day. She also made sure my husband and I always had our favorite drink in hand :)

I recommend using Inn Credible Caterers to anyone getting married in the Hudson Valley.

    ★ ★ ★ ★ ★5.0 

Book them asap. They were outstanding. Great deal, very professional and delicious food!! We got so many compliments from guests on the food and drink. Kayla was our coordinator and she and her team did an incredible job. We had our wedding at Brotherhood Winery on an extremely hot day in August so the cocktail hour had to be moved indoors at the last minute. Kayla's team executed beautifully. It was nice that, on such a stressful day, I did not have to worry about the reception at all because we were in such great hands with Inn Credible. Could not recommend them more. Fantastic.